Summary BESTUFS II national seminar in Hungary 11. 02. 2008. A városi logisztika aktuális kérdései Magyarországon Közlekedési Múzeum Városligeti krt. 11. Budapest At the seminar were 42 participants from different municipalities, ministries, universities, consultancies and transporters/forwarders too. The representatives of more Hungarian cities (Budapest, Szeged, Pécs, Szolnok ad Salgótarján) were involved but in light of the quantity of the sent out invitations this shows unfortunately just a moderate interest regarding city logistics at municipality level. The presentations summarised the theoretical background of city logistics, introduced the BESTUFS project and the Good Practice Guide and presented some practical examples too. The participants were involved very actively in the roundtable discussion after the presentations. The main conclusions are the followings. More projects and investigations would be useful regarding city-logistics to present the importance of these issues to the decision makers. Nowadays on city level generally the political aims beat the experts suggestions so it would be helpful if some organisation eg. (the already existing) Logistics Conciliatory Forum could help the harmonised communication of the different actors within this field against the decision makers. Page 1
Page 2
Participants list Last name First name Company name Mr. Bíró Koppány Ajtony Logisztár Kft. Dr. Bokor Zoltán Ms. Cartwright Éva Bertrans Zrt. Dr. Csaba Attila Magyarországi Logisztikai Szolgáltató Központok Szövetsége Mr. Csello Ferenc Fımterv Zrt. Ms. Dickmann Bernadett Budapesti Corvinus Mr. Dobrocsi Tamás Kozlekedes Kft. Mr. Domonkos Gergely Szeged MJV Polgármesteri Hivatal Fejlesztési Iroda Mr. Fleischer Tamás MTA Világgazdasági Kutatóintézet Mr. Gyöngyösi Imre Logi-Con Tanácsadó Kft. Mr. Horvátth Balázs TRANSMAN Mr. István Zsolt Bay Zoltán Alkalmazott Kutatási Közalapítvány Ms. Ivády Ivett UVT Mr. Karmos Gábor Magyar Kozúti Fuvarozók Egyesülete Mr. Kelemen Gabor Parking Kft. Mr. Kelemen György Pécs Megyei Jogú Város Polgármesteri Hivatala Mr. Kiss Károly FOMTERV Rt. Ms. Kiss Diána Környezetvédelmi Minisztérium Mr. Ladányi Richárd Bay Zoltán Alkalmazott Kutatási Közalapítvány Dr. Legeza Enikı Mr. Lelkes Mihály BFVT Kft. Mr. Lukacs Andras Levegı Munkacsoport Mr. Marjai Gábor ESRI Magyarország kft. Mr. Mihályi Zsolt GKM Dr. Monigl János TRANSMAN Mr. Nógrádi Béla Mr. Oláh Attila ESRI Magyarország kft. Dr. Orosz Csaba Ms. Palásti Szilvia Ms. Pálfy Tünde Dr. Pápay Zsolt Kozlekedes Kft. Ms. Ponta Judit Parking Kft. Page 3
Last name First name Company name BFFH Közlekedési Ügyosztály, Forgalomtechnikai Mr. Potzner Zoltán Alosztály Princz- Mr. Jakovics Tibor TeRRaCe Kft. Mr. Rajku Szilveszter Bertrans Zrt. Szolnoki Ipari Park és Logisztikai Szolgáltató Mr. Simon István Központ Kft. Mr. Strang Tamás Parking Kft. Mr. Szabó István Szolnok város Dr. Tarnai Júlia Ms. Torák Márta Salgótarján megyei jogú város Polgármesteri hivatal Mr. Troszt Norbert i-cell Kft BFFH Közlekedési Ügyosztály, Forgalomtechnikai Mr. Vinkovits Béla Alosztály Page 4
Minutes 11 th of February 2008 Welcome and Introduction 1. Importance and actual questions of city-logistics, by Dr. Janos MONIGL, TRANSMAN Ltd. (HUN) 2. Challenges of city-logistics, by Dr. Eniko LEGEZA, Budapest University of Technology and Economics (HUN) 3. Introduction of the BESTUFS project, by Mr. Balazs HORVATTH, TRANSMAN Ltd.(HUN) 4. ESRI GIS based logistics solutions, by Mr. Attila OLAH, ESRI Hungary Ltd. (HUN) Dinner 5. The zone system that regulates the freight transport of Budapest, by Mr. Gabor KELEMEN, Parking Ltd. (HUN) 6. City logistics relations of the revision of the truck access chares of Budapest, by Mr. Karoly KISS, FİMTERV Co. (HUN) 7. City-logistics questions of the city o Szekesfehervar, by Mr. Koppany Ajtony BIRO, Logisztar Ltd. (HUN) 8. Introduction of the BESTUFS Good Practice Guide, by Mr. Balazs HORVATTH, TRANSMAN Ltd. (HUN) Roundtable discussion After the presentations, a roundtable discussion took place. The following items were raised: City logistics is a very important theme. The BESTUFS project and the Good Practice Guide are good possibilities to motivate the decision makers. The decision makers should be involved more. Final statements The participant expressed that city logistics is a very important issue, but these questions are mostly neglected. On city level generally the political aims beat the experts suggestions. Page 5
List of Presentations 1. Importance and actual questions of city-logistics, by Dr. Janos MONIGL, TRANSMAN Ltd. (HUN) 2. Challenges of city-logistics, by Dr. Eniko LEGEZA, Budapest University of Technology and Economics (HUN) 3. Introduction of the BESTUFS project, by Mr. Balazs HORVATTH, TRANSMAN Ltd.(HUN) 4. ESRI GIS based logistics solutions, by Mr. Attila OLAH, ESRY Hungary Ltd. (HUN) 5. The zone system that regulates the freight transport of Budapest, by Mr. Gabor KELEMEN, Parking Ltd. (HUN) 6. City logistics relations of the revision of the truck access chares of Budapest, by Mr. Karoly KISS, FİMTERV Co. (HUN) 7. Cily-logistics questions of Szekesfehervar city, by Mr. Koppany Ajtony BIRO, Logisztar Ltd. (HUN) 8. Introduction of the BESTUFS Good Practice Guide, by Mr Balazs HORVATTH, TRANSMAN Ltd. (HUN) Page 6