B flhccepxan; HOHHBiH COBCT J\ 203.012,02 na 6ase cdfkoy BO «CaHKX-nexep6yprcKHH OCCHH» 198206, Poccaa, CaHKX-IIexep6ypr, yjı. JlexHHKa ÜHJiıoTOBa, flom 1. OTSWB ııa abtope(j)epat A.B.HnKyjıeHKO na conckahhe ynehoh cxeneı-m floırropa HayK(cneırHajiBHOcxB 12.00.08 -yronobhoe npabo H ; yrojıobho-hcnojihhtejı&hoe npaso): «O6cxoOTejiBCTBa, npecxynhoctb AeaHHa: KOHi^enTyanBHBie OCHOBBI yrojıobho-npaboboh perjıamehtan;hh». CaHKT-IIeTepöypr: CaHKT-nexep6yprcKHH yhhbepchter MB^ POCCHH, 2019. AKxyajı&HOCTB HsöpaHHofi lihkyjıehko A.B. XCMBI HCCjıeflOBatma, no naınemy MH6HHK), HC BBISBIBaeT COMH6HHH, ÜHa Onpe^eJTHeXCÄ KOMniieKCOM nphhhii: BOnepB&ıx, npaboboh H con;hajibhoh npnpo^oh paccmaxpnbaem&ıx ^nccepxaı-ıxom 06-, a ona xakoba, HXO cobepınehhoe HH^OM ^eahhe, cbhsahhoe c npwm- Bpe^a oömecxbeıihbim oxhoınehhhm, oxpanaembim yronobh&im sakohom, cxanobhxca ne XOJIBKO ne npecxynhbim, x.e. npabomepn&im, HO H ^BJiaexcÄ oöıqecx- BCHHO HOJieSHBIM; BO-BXOpBIX, X6M, HXO yrojiobhbi 3ai<OH, (J)OpMyiIHpyK)in:HH OÖcxoHxejiBCXBa, HCKJHonaıomHe npecxynnocxb ^ehhha, ochoban na KOHcxnxyı^HOH- H&IX HopMax 06 OCHOBHBIX npabax H CBOÖo^ax HenoBeı<a ı<aı< Heoxny^KflaeM&ıx H Ka»<^OMy ox pok^ehhfl, noxomy Bcer^a akxyaıibhbim Öy^ex oöpa- K KOHCXHTyu;HOHHBiM HopMaM H aı-ıanhsy na HX OCHOBC HopM yronobhonpaeobbix; B-xpexBHx, ınnpokhm o6m;ecxbehh&im pesohancom, KOxopBiä BBiSBroaex npakxhhecı<oe nphmenehhe cx. cx. 37-42 VK PO B oömecxbe H CMH. Hayqnaa HOBHsna Hccjıe,n,OBaHra sakjiıonaexc^ B TOM, 'qxo ^HccepxaHT nonbixaıtacb BocnojiHHXB npoöen B HaynnoM OCMBICJICHHH H npakxhheckom nphmenehhh HCKJiıoHaıomHx npecxynhocxb fle^hha, npe^ycmoxpehh&ıx rjıasoh 8
YK PO, a xaıoke HHBIX oöcxoflxejı&cxb, noı-ca HC nojıyhhbinnx sakoı-ıo^atejibhoro sa- KpenjıenHfl. TmaxejiBHO HsyneHBi H npobepeıı&ı ııa npe^mex COOXBCXCXBHH nopmam YrojıoBHoro Ko^eKca POCCHH H HHBIC HopMaxHBHBie npabobbie akxbi, peryjınpyıo- Hine ochobafflm H ycjıobna npabomepnoro nphhhnehns Bpe.ua npn BBinojiHenHH npo^ecchohan&hbix oöaaahhocxen coxpy^hhkamh npabooxpahhxenbhbix H HHBIX rocy^apcxbehi-ı&ıx opranob. PaspaöoxaHH&ıe ^HCcepxaHXOM KOHn;enxyajı&H&ıe OCHOBBI yronobho-npaboboh oöcxootejibcxb, HCKJnoHaıomHX npecxynhoctb FJiy6oKO o6ochobahhbimh H HMCIOmHMH HpKO BBIpa)KeHHOe ı<ak B ccjjepe sakohoxbopnecxba npn (J3opMyjiHpoBaHHH cooxbexcxbyıo- LH;HX ^osbojihxejibhbix ııopm YK POCCHH, xak H npabonphmehhxenbhot ccj^epe npn KBanH(J)HKai];HH nphhhhehhh Bpe.ua npn oöcxo^xejibctbax, HCKjnonaıomHX npecxyn- HOCXB RQXHm.. npe^jioacehbi asxopckhe peflaı<:n;hh cooxbexcxbyroıxıxıx nopm, (c. 13-18). PesyjiBxax&ı Hccne^oBaHH^ nosbojihjin abxopy BBMBHTB necobepnıenctba, a B OX^ JIB- H&IX cjıynanx H npo6ejibi sakono^axejibctba, npe^no>khxb pekomchäa^hh no ero MO/ı;epHH3aıı,HH. Ox^eJiBHOH cxpokoh cjıeflyex OXMCXHXB ycnenmyk), na nara Bsrjıa^, nonbixky abxopa HcxojiKOBaxB H sakoho^axejibho sakpennxb nopmy 06 ouih6ı<e B oöcxoaxejibcxbax, HCKJnonaıoL^HX npecxynhoctb ^e^hha (c. 17). K HHCJiy ^OCXOHHCXB cne^yex oxhecxn H npe^jiaraemyıo nopmy cx. 39 l (npa- BOMepHaa npobokaı^hh). Bc^FiecKoro oaoöpehna sacny^hbaıox npe^jıaraembie H3- Meı-ıerora B cx. cx. 61 H 62 YK PO, a xak^ce ccjjopmyjihpobanhoe nororrae o6cxoa- XCJILCXB, HCKJnonaıomHX npecxynhocxb ^CJIHHH. K HHCjıy HecoMHeHH&ıx flocxohhcxb AHccepxaıjHH HnKyjreı-iKo A.B. cjıe^yex OXHCCXH: MeagpıcmniJiHHapHBiH xapaxxep nccjıe^obahha, BKnıoHa^ yroırobhonpaboboh, KpHMHHOJIOFHHeCKHH H HCXOpOTeCKHH acnekxhj CpaBHHXejTBHO-npaBOBOH anajihs ÖonBinoro MaccnBa 3apy6e5KHoro saıcohoflaxejibcxba no XCMC flnccepxan;hh (c. 25). "' öasa npobeflehnoro Hccjıe^oBaHHa: ona 2
B ceöa nomhmocxaxhcxhheckhx ^ahh&ıx o npecxynjieiihax, cobepnıeııııwx npn ı-ıapynıehhh ycjıobhh npabomepnocxn nphhhheıiha Bpe^a npn oöcxoaxejibcxbax, HC- KJiıoHaıoLqHX npecxynnocxb KGXHKX, MaxepnajiBi cy^eöhoh H cjıeflcxbehhoh npakxh- KH sa nepho,n: c 2011 r. no 2018 rr.: ^BIJIO Hsyneno 188 MaxepnajıoB, no KOXOPBIM BBiHeceHBi nocxanobjiehhfl 06 oxıcase B B03Öy)K#eHHH H npekpameımh yroııobhbix RQJI B CBSSH c HajiHHH M oöcxoflxejibcxb, HCKJnoHaroDXHX npecxynnocxb ^eahna; 47 yrojıobhbix K&JI, no KoxopBiM ÖBIJTH BBineceHBi onpab^axejibhbie nphrobopbi no XCM )Ke ochobahhäm; 242 yronobhbix ^ejıa, CBflsamiBix c 3Kcn;eccoM OÖCXOOTCJIBCXB, HC- KJiK)Haıoııı,HX npecxyıihocxb ^eahha; MaxepnajiBi 44 npeflbapnxejibhbix npobepok no 4)aı<xaM nphmchehh^ ornecxpejı&horo opyacna, cnen;hai[bhbix HJIH ^HSHHCCKOH chjı&ı cotpy^hhkamh npabooxpaiihxenbhbix opranob sa nepno^ 2011-2018 rr., a xaıcace pesyn&xaxbi abxopckhx ankexii&ıx onpocob H HHBIX COHHOonpocoB: ABxopOM npobe^ehbi cou;hojiorhheckhe nccjıeflobahhh no npoöjıem o6cxoaxejibcxb, HCKJiıoHaıomHx npecxynhoqxb fleahha. OnporneHO 320 cnenhajihcxob, B HHCJIC KOXOpBix nay^ho-neflarorhheckhe pa6oxhhkh B o6jıacxh yrojıobhoro npasa, KpHMHi-ıonoraH H npabo oxpaiihxejibhoh H npakxhkh - cjıe^obaxenh OBfl H CK P<I>, npokypopckhe paöoxnnkh, pajibh&ıx cy^ob H cy^ob cyötekxa Pct>, a xak5ke 112 OÖBIHHLIX rpaacaan (c. 19). IlojıyHeHHBie conckaxejiem pesyjibxaxbi H BBIBO^BI oxpa>kchbi B cxa flbyx ny6jihi<a^hax, B XOM nncjıe ^Ba^^axH xpex B BeAyrn,Hx pe^enshpyem&ıx H&IX ^cypnajıax, BxoflHinHx B nepenenb BAK MnHHCxepcxBa o6pa30bahh^ H naykh PO, MOHorpa(J)HH, ^Byx yneöhhkax, xpex yneöhbix nocoön^ıx, ıcypce JieK^HH no yronobhomy npaby, HayHHO-npaKXH^ecKOM ÜOCOÖHH, KOMMenxapnH K YrojıoBHOMy KO- eı<cy PO (B xpex xomax), yneöı-ihke, B KoxopBix cohckaxenb ÄBJIJUICÄ nayhhbim pe-, H ^pyrnx paöoxax asxopa, OÖIHHM OÖ^ÖMOM CBBime 125 n.ji., a B oöpasobaxenbhbih H HayHHbiH npon;ecc CaHKx-IIexepöyprcKoro BepcHxexa MB ( POCCHH, Bojırorpa^CKOH aka^emhh MB^ POCCHH, PoccHHCKoro rocy^apcxbenhoro ne^arorhheckoro ynhbepcnxexa HM. A. H. Fep^ena, a xaıoxe B npakxhheckyıo Ae^TejiBHOCxB npabooxpahhxejibhbix opraııob H cy^ob 3
HBIH ^enapxamenx npn MHHHCxepcxBe BHyxpenHHx ^CJT POCCHHCKOH FnaBHoe cjıe^cxbehnoe ynpabjienhe npn FY MB^ POCCHH no r. CanKT-FIeTepöypry H JleHHHrpaflCKOH oöjiacxh, CaHKx-Flexep6yprcKHH ropo^ckoh cy;ı) (c. 19-20). PesyjiBxax&ı /pıccepxarihohhoro Hccne^oBaHHH npoxoflhjin anpo6au;hk> B BHfle ^OKJia^OB H cooömehhh cohckaxejm na 112 HaynHO-npaKXHHecKHX H HHBIX 4>opyMax (H3 KOXOpBIX 61 MOKflyi-iapO^HOrO H BCepOCCHHCKOrO ypobhä, BKJIIOHaa POCCHHCKHH Konrpecc yrojıobhoro npasa B MTY HM. M.B. JIoMoııocoBa) B MOCKBC (2011, 2013, 2015, 2018), CaHKx-nexepöypre (2011-2018), KasanH (2011, 2012, 2014), Eı<axepHHÖypre (2012), CnM^eponojıe (2017, 2018), Bonrorpafle (2016, 2017, 2018), Poc- XOBC (2018), KypcKe (2016, 2017, 2018), KajiHHHHrpa^e (2011, 2013, 2015, 2018), HoBocApcKe (2016, 2017), Jlnneıpce (2014, 2015, 2016, 2018). B ıjejıom HCOÖXOÄHMO KoncxaxHpoBaxB, HXO npe^cxabjieı-ihbih abxopecjdepax CO,Hep»CHX flocxaxohhyk) HIKJJOpMai^HIO O ^CCepXaiIHOHHOM HCCJie^OBaHHH, HXO o BBICOKOM HayHHOM H npakxhheckom ypobhe paöpxbi, HsyneHHH H snahhxejibhoro o6ı>ema xeopexhhecı<oro H HopMaxHBHoro Maxepuana. BMCCXC c XCM, HecMOxp^ na BBICOKHH ypobeıib paöoxbi, oöocnobahhocxb nanojio^kchhh, BBIBO^OB H pekomeh^a^hh, HX ^OCXOBepHOCXB H HOBHSHy, HpaK- XHHecı<yıo snahhmocxb, cjıe^yet yı<a3ax& H na xo, HXO ona ne JiHineı-ıa onpe^ejıemibix He^ocxaxKOB, B HacxHOCxn: 1. Ha naın Bsrjıa^, asxop npoabhji HSJIHDIHIOK) CKPOMHOCXB, H HC npe,ıı;jıo- 5KHJI B KanecxBe nonoacehhh, BBIHOCHMBIX na samnxy, HOJIHOCXBK) abxopckyıo pe- ^aku;hh HOpM Bceiı raabbi 8 YrojıOBHoro KO^eKca POCCHHCKOH Oe^epanHH. 2. He Bnojıne COOXHOCHXC^ c nosmiheh asxopa 06 HCKJnoneHHH cx. 42 YK P<D, co BCC JKQ npefljıaraemoh ee pe^ak^heh. C flpyrofi cxopohbi, MBI nojiaraem, HXO B cymecxbobahhe xakoboh nopmbi B YK OKasBisaex nosnxhbhoe SHaneHHe na conpecxynnocxh B ^ahhofi c<j)epe H cny>knx ^onojihhxejı&hbim cxhmynom cosakohhocxn Kaı< fljıa pykobo^hxejıeii, xak H JIHD;, o6»3ahh&ıx no HJIH pa6oxbi HcnojınaxB cooxbexcxbyıomhe nphkasbi (pacnop5i>kehm). 4
3. H nocne^hee, fljıs CMBICJIOBOFO sabepıneı-ih^ pa6oth ne JIHIIIHHM ÖBIJIO ÖBI npeflcxabjiehhe npoeıcxa HSMeneHHH B Oe^epajiBHbie SEKOHBI, penıamehxhochobanns H nop^mok nphmehenna (f>h3hhecko i CHJIBI, cneıpıajibhbix H oraecxpejibhoro opy^khji, B nacxhocxh, N 3-O3 «O IIOJIHI];HH», KOTOPBIH, Kaı< npe^cxabjiaexc^ Bepo^ıxı-iBiM, nanöojıee ÖJIHSOK ^HCcepxaHxy, ^BJiaıomeMy coxpy^hhkom opranob BHyxpenHHX RQJI POCCHH H HMeıomeMy Henocpe,n;cxBeHH&iH on&ıx peajihsaıihh XHX sakoho^axejibhbix ycxanobjıehhh, nero o^hako c^ejıano ne ÖBIJIO. Asxop orpahhhhjic^: JIHIHB KOHCxaxan;HeH Heoöxo^HMocxH nphbe^ehh^ XHX SaKOHOB B COOXBCXCXBHe C yrojiobhbim KO^CKCOM POCCHH. B xo)ke BpeM5[ oxmexhm, Hxo nocxabjienh&ıe BonpocBi H c^ejıahhbie He BJIH^IOX B ^ejıom Ha BecBMa Ha nojıo^thxejibhyıo ou;ehky paöox&ı. TaKHM oöpasom, MO>KHO c^ejıaxb BBIBO^, HXO, cy^a no aırropec^epaxy, xau;iia na conckahhe ynehoh cxenehh ^oı-cxopa IOPHAHHCCKHX nayk«06cxoaxejibcxba, HCKnıoHaronTHe npecxynhocxb ^eahhe: KOH^enaryanbHLie OCHO- B&I yrojiobho-npaboboh perjıamehxan;hh», nofl,roxobjiehhaa A. B. HtiKyneHKO cxabjiaex COÖOH pesyjibxax ray6okoro xbopneckoro HccneflOBaHH^ BecBMa HOH H BaHHoiı HayHHOH npoöncmbi, HanncaHa abxopom camocxo^xenbho, o6na#aex BHyxpeı-iHHM e^hhgxbom, co^ep^khx HOBBie ı-ıayhhbie pesynbxaxbi H nojioacehna, BBInyöJiHHHOH saınhxbi, H CBH^exejiBCXByex o JIHHHOM BKna^e asxopa B nayky. Ona ^BJiaexca HaynHo-KBajiH(J)HKa^HOHHOH paöoxon, B KOXOpoö na ochobahhh BBinojiHeHHoro abxopom Hccjıe^OBaHH^ paspaöoxanbi xeopexh^e- CKHC nojıokehna, cobokynnocxb KoxopBix MO)KHO ou;ehhxb ı<aı< nayhhoe ^ocxn^ce- HHe, cocxoamee B peınehhh nayhhoh npo6jıembi, HMeıomeH Baacnoe yrojıobhonpasoboe SHaneHHe. Hccjıe^oBaHHe oxbenaex npefl-babjiäembim K flokxopckhm flhccepxaı^mim xpe-, ycxanobjiehhbim nyhkxamh 9-10 HojıoKeHHa «O nopaflke npncy»caehha cxeneneh», yxseph^ehhoro nocxahobnenhem ripabhxejibcxba PO 24 cen- 2013 r. JYe 842 (B pe^. ox loxxaöpa 2018 r.), a ee asxop An^pe BHH HnKyjıeHKO sacjıy^chbaex nphcy>k^eiih5i emy HCKOMOH yneı-ıoh cxenehh
HayK no cneıihajibhocth 12.00.08 - yrojıobi-ıoe npabo H KPHMHHOJIOrm.', yrojıobi-ıo-hcnojihhtejibhoe npabo. HesaBHCHMoro HpocJDcoıosa paöothhkob HaıiHOHanBHOH AKafleMHH HayK AsepöaHA^Kana floktop loph^hheckhx HayK no cneu;hajibhocth 12.00.08 -yronobhoe npabo H KpHMHHOJiorM; yrojıobho-hcnojihhxejibhoe npabo, npo< )eccop FaÖHjı KypöanoB a^pec: AZ1073, AsepöaHAXKaı-ıcı-cajr PecnyönHKa, r. Baı<y, 115, Pa6. TCJIC^OH (+99412) 539-23-46, Mo6. Tejıe^on (+99450) 220 00 20, JIBKxpOHH&iH a^pec: professorqurbanov@yandex.com 6